People's Army of Sonoma

Most of you probably already know this:

Endless Decanter of Water

To obtain, throw a full water pitcher at a water elemental (non summoned) there is a slight chance the elemental will throw back to the player a Endless Decanter of Water. The Decanter can then be linked to a water trough, as long as the player is within 5 tiles outside of a house or anywhere inside a house the Decanter will continuously refill itself.

Have you been able to get one? I'm interested in trying, but not if the chance is 1 in 1000 or something like that.

They are real easy to get. If you take around 50 pitchers of water with you, you should average getting around 6-10 back as Endless Decanters of Water. Once a water el gives you the pitcher, that el can no longer be used, so kill him and go after another one.